Skip to content
The Agentic Operator

Issue 5 ·

I tested Athletic Greens on ChatGPT

They're only 25% visibility despite $100M+ in revenue and celebrity endorsements

By Ankit Minocha. Founder, Atomz.

I tested Athletic Greens on ChatGPT

I searched buy daily vitamins for energy boost in ChatGPT.

Athletic Greens - the $100M+ brand with celebrity endorsements and massive marketing spend - was nowhere to be found.

Welcome to AI Brand Audits - where I dig into how brands actually perform when customers shop with AI.

Today’s edition: Athletic Greens (AG1)

Athletic Greens built the premium greens powder category through aggressive marketing and celebrity partnerships with Andrew Huberman and Tim Ferriss.

But I wanted to see: Does $100M+ in revenue translate to AI visibility?

The AI Test

  • 12 purchase-intent queries across ChatGPT-4

  • Fresh sessions to avoid context contamination

  • Tested category authority, price positioning, use cases, and health benefits

  • All the details and screenshots are here.

Where Athletic Greens actually appears

  1. Buy greens powder for gut health and immunity
    AG1 highlighted at $158 with gut health and immunity positioning

  2. Best greens supplement with probiotics
    Strong showing when probiotics specifically mentioned

  3. Shop comprehensive daily nutrition powder
    Positioned as premium, all-in-one solution

Where they completely vanish

  1. Buy superfood powder online
    What appeared:
    Bloom Nutrition ($26.97), Pure Synergy ($64.00), Daily Greens ($40.00)

  2. Daily vitamins for energy boost
    What appeared:
    Solaray Once Daily ($46.59), New Chapter Every Woman's One Daily ($18.00), New Chapter Perfect Energy ($60.00)

  3. Shop all-in-one nutrition powder 
    What appeared:
    Vega All-in-One ($69.99), Ka'Chava ($29.99), Pure Protein ($27.99)

  4. Best alternative to Ritual vitamins
    What appeared:
    Momentous Multivitamin ($54.95), Multi for Plant-Based People ($38.99), Love Wellness ($19.99)

The premium positioning trap

Athletic Greens' data creates a clear pattern:

They own "gut health immunity greens" but are invisible for "daily energy vitamins" - despite energy being a core benefit they market.

The pattern

AG1 ONLY appeared in searches that specifically mentioned:

  • Gut health + immunity

  • Probiotics

  • Comprehensive daily nutrition

They were completely invisible in:

  • Energy-focused searches (0/3)

  • Value/affordable searches (0/2)

  • Alternative/competitive searches (0/3)

  • General category searches (0/1)

 

Wonder if your brand has the same gaps?

I built a free tool that tests your brand across multiple AI systems in 2 minutes.

Check your brand's AI visibility →

You'll see exactly which searches find you (and which don't).

 
Why this happens (I checked their product pages):

I went to their AG1 product page to see what they're actually saying.

Here's what I found. Their page emphasizes:

  • 75 vitamins, minerals, and whole-food ingredients

  • Comprehensive daily nutrition

  • Gut health and immune support

What's missing for their AI discovery:

  • Never emphasizes "energy boost" despite marketing it heavily

  • No problem-solving language like "tired in afternoon" or "low energy"

  • Missing keywords like "multivitamin alternative" or "meal replacement"

Customer searches target:

  • Daily vitamins for energy

  • Affordable superfood powder

  • Alternative to traditional multivitamins

AI can't connect "75 vitamins and minerals" to "energy boost vitamins." The information is there, but wrapped in premium comprehensive nutrition messaging.

The price ceiling effect

AG1's $158/month pricing consistently excludes them from value-conscious searches where Bloom Nutrition ($26.97) and Huel ($45.50) dominate.

The not-so-surprising winner?

Bloom Nutrition at $26.97 appeared across multiple searches where AG1 was missing - superfood powder, daily wellness, gut-friendly supplements. They have nailed their product pages!

 
What you should do about this for your brand

Step 1: Test your baseline (takes 2 minutes):
Before you change anything, see where you actually stand. Run your free AI visibility test →

Step 2: Once you know your gaps from Step 1, fix your messaging:

  • List 10 ways customers search for your products
    - Beyond "comprehensive nutrition," what daily problems do you solve?

  • Check your top product pages
    - Are you describing premium positioning or solving specific problems?

  • Compare your language to competitors who ARE showing up
    - What keywords are they using that you're not?

Step 3: Fix your content structure

  • Add problem-solution language to product descriptions
    Instead of "75 vitamins and minerals," try "Daily energy and gut health support with 75 nutrients"

  • Include functional keywords
    If you solve energy problems, actually say "energy boost" not just "comprehensive nutrition"

  • Create FAQ sections matching search queries
    "What's good for afternoon energy crashes?" not just "What's in AG1?"

This is exactly why we built Atomz AI. Most brands already have the right product data - it's just not organized in a way AI systems can understand.

We help restructure your catalog so your products show up for the right searches, whether someone's looking for premium comprehensive solutions or trying to solve "I'm tired at 2pm every day."

You can Try Atomz Cataloging Agent for free to automatically generate product pages in this format

Track and optimize:

  • Re-run your AI visibility test monthly to track improvement

  • Monitor which product pages get found vs which don't

  • Test descriptions with AI before publishing

 

The bigger picture

Premium-positioned brands face a discovery paradox: they optimize for comprehensive quality and trust, but customers search for solutions to specific problems.

Your $100M+ revenue won't help if people searching for "energy boost vitamins" can't find you.

That's it for this one!

Hope it got you thinking about how premium brand messaging plays out in AI search.

Happy AI'ing!

Best,
Ankit Minocha
https://atomz.ai

PS: If you test your brand and find something interesting, please do me a favor, and hit reply and tell me. I'm collecting all these patterns.

PS2: I love geeking on AI, Coffee & Cars. Let's chat!

If this was useful, the next one will be too.

Weekly. Free.

Unsubscribe with one click.